provides betterment to the current situation
...when the current situation is virtually no livestock crossing that road.
In 1965, Straitgate Farm near Ottery St Mary in Devon was bought by ECC Quarries in the hope it would yield 20 million tonnes of sand & gravel. In 2001, Straitgate Action Group was formed to oppose the development and its potential harm to water supplies, ancient wetland habitats, protected species and much more. In 2023, Aggregate Industries – owned by Swiss giant Holcim – was finally granted permission to quarry just 1 million tonnes following a public inquiry. This blog records the story.
provides betterment to the current situation
...when the current situation is virtually no livestock crossing that road.
A planning application for a new cattle crossing over the B3174 Exeter Road is also being finalised for submission to EDDC.
The area of the existing agricultural holding extends to some 120.78 acres (48.9ha)… The application site covers an area extending to some 42.5ha, with mineral extraction proposed to take place within 22.6ha with the remainder of the site occupied by temporary soil storage bunds, mitigation planting and site management and access areas. 2.1.10
The provision of a Cattle crossing over the B3174 may have severe impact on the operation of the B3174, which in the absence of assessment is not known.
the impacts should be factored into the safety assessments and traffic calculations.
6.1 In certain circumstances it may become necessary for the farm tenant to move the dairy herd over to the south of the B3174 to access other grazing land owned by the tenant’s family.
6.2 The new access will reduce disruption to vehicles, during periods when cattle traverse the public highway and increase safety for both the tenant farmer and road users.
6.5 The substantially reduced distance of crossing will shorten the time taken to cross the herd over the public highway and potentially reduce the transfer of mud onto the highway itself.
6.6 The proposed crossing therefore provides betterment to the current diagonal crossing point which both the tenant farmer and road users will benefit from.
6.7 It is considered that there are no material considerations why planning permission should not be granted.
Oh it's OK, he's got all the warning signs and things!
— Arundodonuts (@Arundodonuts) December 14, 2020
The space left in the atmosphere for further concentrations of carbon dioxide is the ultimate scarce resource, and it needs to be priced accordingly - Mark Lewis, BNP Paribas
Assumptions of future technologies and targets decades ahead delay immediate action. Countries and corporations must shift focus from distant net zero targets to real emissions reductions now.
We must shift focus from mid-century net-zero targets to immediate, real emissions reductions in our own high-income countries. Reductions of at least 10% per year are needed. This massive transformation of our societies is our only way to fulfil the Paris agreement without relying on risky and unproven, large-scale deployment of negative emission technologies.
Processing at Hillhead may be feasible, but would generate a massively greater quantity of CO2 emissions from the additional mileage required to be travelled.
NEW TODAY: The #CDPAList 2020!
— CDP (@CDP) December 8, 2020
Congratulations to the companies earning places on our 2020 Climate, Forests & Water A Lists, for their leadership in tackling environmental risks through corporate transparency: https://t.co/t04LTMnvwq pic.twitter.com/ZERi9L23MF
Distant hypothetical targets are being set, and big speeches are being given. Yet, when it comes to the immediate action we need, we are still in a state of complete denial, as we waste our time, creating new loopholes with empty words and creative accounting.
If only words, pledges and setting distant hypothetical targets actually lowered our emissions then we wouldn't still be in this mess.
— Greta Thunberg (@GretaThunberg) December 2, 2020
The longer we pretend we can "fix this" without treating the crisis like a crisis, the more invaluable time we'll loose.#FaceTheClimateEmergency
"This ranking confirms how committed we are to driving our #netzero journey, with the most ambitious CO2 targets in our sector. This is a great testimony to the dedication of our teams, making climate action part of everything we do." @AndersonMagali_ CSO#Netzero #ClimateAction pic.twitter.com/6i5vODwzCW
— LafargeHolcim (@LafargeHolcim) December 8, 2020
HeidelbergCement confirms climate change leadership with CDP ‘A’ #rating https://t.co/PRB6jkPFAB #CDPAList pic.twitter.com/JjFXyb2bZc
— HeidelbergCement (@hd_cement) December 8, 2020
By scoring companies from D- to A, we take them on a journey through disclosure to awareness, management, and finally to leadership. Our scoring measures the comprehensiveness of disclosure, awareness and management of environmental risks and best practices associated with environmental leadership, such as setting ambitious and meaningful targets.
The A List showcases the companies leading on environmental transparency and action, based on their annual disclosure through CDP’s climate change, forests and water security questionnaires. Thousands of companies disclose through CDP at the request of investors and corporate buyers. This year has seen a major increase (45% up on last year) in the number of companies achieving an A score, with increases across all three themes that CDP assesses. Along with the high levels of disclosure, this shows growing environmental awareness among the business world in 2020. For climate scores this is largely because more companies are choosing to be transparent by disclosing data – in itself an important step, driven by increased market pressure for transparency.
In addition, we received a score of A- in the @CDP ranking for water, which places the Group in the CDP’s Leadership band. This score recognizes LafargeHolcim's implementation of current best practices with regards to water performance and transparency.https://t.co/4WRg2sRWmY pic.twitter.com/iGD5FR2tVR
— LafargeHolcim (@LafargeHolcim) December 8, 2020
The change in the sharing of data has come about following a review of our practice in this area and is now in-line with company policy.
🔔 The Interim Devon Carbon Plan is now LIVE!
— Devon Climate Emergency (@devonclimate) December 7, 2020
The plan is a collaborative roadmap to a net-zero Devon where people and nature thrive.
We are asking you to feedback on key actions required to create a thriving net-zero Devon.
Have your say ➡️ https://t.co/VC5GwomB43 pic.twitter.com/4HnLxBzQLL
This Plan lays out a roadmap for Devon to achieve net-zero carbon by 2050 at the latest, with an interim target of 50% reduction by 2030 below 2010 levels.
Net-zero Devon will be quite different from how it is now. Achieving net-zero will have strong spatial components, and so will need to be spatially planned for. Where things are in Devon and how they connect shapes most areas of our lives, it is a cross cutting issue and driver of GHG emissions.
Transport accounts for 31% of Devon’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The sector is the single largest emitter of GHG across the County, which also reflects the UK-wide position. Reducing emissions from transport is key to successfully reaching net-zero.
CEMEX's commitment to #sustainable transport methods has enabled us to transport 2 million tonnes of aggregates across the UK by rail this year. This has saved over 12,500 tonnes of #CO2 compared to using trucks 🚆 head here to read more: https://t.co/ZTtSwyeicx pic.twitter.com/kOT0PiWlwl
— CEMEX Policy EU (@CEMEXPolicyEU) December 1, 2020
Last week we delivered the first #Train into our Cricklewood Terminal on behalf @Hanson_UK and Mendip Rail Limited. As part of the new contract, DB Cargo UK will transport significant volumes of aggregates from Tytherington Quarry in Gloucestershire into London. #Freight pic.twitter.com/dNWBIo5vlN
— DB Cargo UK (@DBCargoUK) December 10, 2020
Every week DB Cargo UK transports in the region of 7,200 tonnes of china clay for @Imerys in covered hopper wagons – this removes around 11,000 lorries a year off Cornwall’s road network.#TeamRed pic.twitter.com/jWDSsXCtip
— DB Cargo UK (@DBCargoUK) November 19, 2020
10-year deal signed between @DBCargoUK and Brett Aggregates to move sea-dredged products from Ipswich, Cliffe and Newhaven. #railfreight pic.twitter.com/2PkJ5TZsgy
— Richard Clinnick (@Richard_rail) November 4, 2020
Freightliner has been awarded a new contract with the UK’s leading sustainable construction solutions company, @TarmacLtd
— Freightliner (@RailFreight) September 22, 2020
Under the new contract, Freightliner will haul aggregate from Tarmac's Tunstead site & their West Country quarries.#railfreighthttps://t.co/SHrugu7r4E pic.twitter.com/qndwdF1T0p
Every aggregate freight train takes 70-75 lorries off the road. MPA and @railfreightUK set out the benefits of rail freight for aggregates here: https://t.co/l8AESCrb0J https://t.co/PpAVyHTWty
— Mineral Products Association (@MineralProduct) August 25, 2020
The company had been notified in planning documents that it would first need to obtain the appropriate mitigation and a Natural England European protected species licence.
Bellway housebuilders fined £600,000 for destroying bat roost in south London https://t.co/Cv1pvfJcbL
— Guardian news (@guardiannews) December 11, 2020
An extensive amount of important hedgerow will be destroyed. This is completely irreversible. The hedgerows are… likely to have existed for centuries… Compensation planting… for losses of irreplaceable habitat should be at a ratio in the region of 30 – 1. Proposed replanting and that already done falls far short of this.
Devon County Council’s development management committee... voted to approve the scheme by seven votes to five, with two abstentions, after an initial vote to refuse was lost via the casting vote of committee chairman Cllr Jerry Brook after a 7-7 deadlock.
... the proposed operation would degrade rather than conserve and enhance the landscape character and visual quality of the Haldon Hills Area of Great Landscape Value for a period of between 10 to 15 years, and significant adverse effects would not be mitigated to acceptable levels, therefore contrary to Policies W2, W12 and W18 of the Devon Waste Plan, Policy EN2A of the Teignbridge Local Plan and NPPF paragraphs 130 and 170.
An Area of Great Landscape Value (AGLV) is an area of land in England which is considered to be of high landscape quality with strong distinctive characteristics which make them particularly sensitive to development. The designation was established under the Town and Country Planning Act 1947. Within ALGVs the primary objective is conservation and enhancement of their landscape quality and individual character.
Taken in isolation, the landscape and visual impacts of the proposed development are such as to warrant refusal of the application due to the significant harm to the landscape character and visual quality of the AGLV for the duration of the landraising operation…. It is necessary, however, to weigh the adverse landscape impact against the contribution that the proposed facility would make to maintaining sufficient capacity for the disposal of inert waste materials within the Exeter area.
Whitestone landfill plans means ‘nature’s playground will become Exeter’s dumping ground’https://t.co/FsRQvanUPm
— Devon Live News (@DevonLiveNews) December 3, 2020
Devon CPRE 'dismayed' at approval of landfill site in Area of Great Landscape Value @cpredevon @thealanquick @DevonCC @DevComsTogether @Teignbridge #Crediton #Whitestone #landfill https://t.co/XtxuyqP19G
— Crediton Courier (@CreditonCourier) December 11, 2020
This is not going to end well https://t.co/QXUomJrH0R
— Kailas Wild 🐨🌳 (@kailaswild) December 11, 2020
The dominant categories in the analysis were human-made mass in the form of buildings and infrastructure, composed of concrete, aggregates, bricks and asphalt.
Focusing on the recycling sector, CDE’s Eunan Kelly, Head of RECO, was joined by a panel of construction, demolition and excavation waste pioneers to discuss challenges and opportunities for sustainable construction in the UK and Ireland. Commenting on the sharp rise in public awareness of sustainability issues, Scott Brewster, Managing Director at Brewster Bros. Ltd, said, “There’s never been a time in history when the general public have been more informed about the environmental crisis we face.” He referenced how self-discipline and external pressures are leading a shift in how companies in the construction industry operate, citing they have become “leaner and cleaner” for their adoption of recycled aggregates which is improving profit margins and reducing environmental impact. As well as public pressure, he believes political pressure, including ambitious zero waste and net-zero emissions targets, and fiscal pressures, such as landfill tax and the aggregates levy, will encourage more construction businesses to turn to high quality recycled sand and aggregate products.
Viv Russell of Longcliffe Quarries and James Thorne from the Institute of Quarrying joined with CDE to discuss the hidden value in by-product stockpiles. Russell explained, “A lot of things have changed over the years. Certainly, overburden was something you would muck away… and potentially, in the life of a quarry, you would move around three or four times. “You can’t afford to transport this material anymore,” he added. Pressures and influences on the industry, such as the Aggregates Levy in 2002, meant that a solution to costly waste products had to be found. Russell continued, “Touching them [the waste products] once and turning them into a product is common sense. Now scalpings and crushed rock fines…once seen as a waste are now seen as a resource.” Commenting on the evolution in practice in the industry, Thorne said, “The drivers are changing and the industry is moving its focus to reflect that.”
CDE symposium examined trends and challenges in the materials processing industry. #Quarry #Mining #Crushing #Screening #Plant #Equipment @cdeglobal https://t.co/j1zuKKx2qD
— Highways.Today (@HighwaysToday) December 1, 2020
a public act with very little associated cost that is intended to inform others of one's socially acceptable alignment on an issue.
Accusing someone of virtue signalling is to accuse them of a kind of hypocrisy. The accused person claims to be deeply concerned about some moral issue but their main concern is – so the argument goes – with themselves. They’re not really concerned with changing minds, let alone with changing the world, but with displaying themselves in the best light possible.
the practice of professing standards, beliefs, etc, contrary to one's real character or actual behaviour especially the pretence of virtue and piety
the false profession of desirable or publicly approved qualities, beliefs, or feelings, especially a pretense of having virtues, moral principles, or religious beliefs that one does not really possess.
carry fire in one hand and water in the other. To be duplicitous, to engage in double-dealing; to be two-faced, to speak with forked tongue. The expression comes from Plautus; it continues “to bear a stone in one hand, a piece of bread in the other.” Thus, the expression indicates that a person is prepared to act in totally contradictory ways to achieve his purposes.
Our communities and our economy are enduring not only a devastating pandemic but also the rising costs of climate change. Record wildfires, flooding, hurricanes and other extreme weather are upending lives and livelihoods. And science makes clear that future generations will face far greater environmental, economic and health impacts unless we act now.
We’re taking steps toward a #netzero economy, but effectively tackling climate change requires strong federal policy solutions. In the US, we’ve joined 42 leading companies and @C2ES_org in calling for ambitious, durable, bipartisan climate policy.https://t.co/tmfgh2gMcD pic.twitter.com/2CT6JJvr8Q
— LafargeHolcim (@LafargeHolcim) December 3, 2020
@LafargeHolcim is very proud to be part of the 42!
— MagaliAnderson (@AndersonMagali_) December 6, 2020
.@_EricOlsen If you want to #ActOnClimate & #CO2 why is @LafargeHolcim @AggregateUK planning a 2.5 million mile haulage scheme across Devon? pic.twitter.com/MQy66zijL4
— Straitgate Action Gp (@straitgateactgp) February 14, 2017
Dear Mr Edwards,
You will be aware of the intense and growing focus on ESG issues, not only by the public and media, but also by the investment world; LafargeHolcim tapped the latter only last week with an €850 million sustainability-linked bond.
Given that Aggregate Industries claims “sustainability is at the heart of our business, and is incorporated in all of our operations”, we would be interested in any comments you may have about the company’s planning application in Devon for a new sand and gravel quarry at Straitgate Farm.
You may already know of this application. Over the last decade, your company has struggled to address the many constraints linked with this site, not least on groundwater. The irreversible damage to the many surrounding private water supplies and Grade I listed Cadhay from your company’s proposal has been unequivocally set out in a damning report by leading authority Professor Brassington.
Your company’s application is for "up to 1.5 million tonnes of as raised sand and gravel". However, significantly less than a million tonnes of saleable material would be recovered, given that waste accounts for 20% of that figure, and elevated groundwater levels have yet to be factored in. This ignores the fact that similar local sites, Marshbroadmoor and Venn Ottery, respectively yielded 80% and 50% less than forecast due to geological constraints.
However, what sets the Straitgate application apart – at a time that councils and the UK government have declared a climate emergency – is the issue of sustainability.
Your company is proposing a 46 mile round trip to process every as-dug load; a staggering 2.5 million miles in total – before any onward delivery of finished product.
No other UK aggregates operator has 23 miles separating quarry face and processing plant. Clearly this – together with Aggregate Industries’ lamentable progress reducing carbon emissions – sends the unequivocal message to the wider world that sustainability is neither at the heart of your business nor incorporated into all of your operations.
You can google Straitgate for further information.
We look forward to hearing from you.
With the government committing to producing ‘net zero’ greenhouse gases by 2050, the construction industry’s role in safeguarding the future of our planet has never been more prevalent.
While the magnitude of the task facing us in achieving ‘net zero’ is clear, we’re confident that a forward-thinking, progressive industry like ours will take up the mantel and lead the way in demonstrating the lengths we can go to reduce our environmental impact, which will positively impact us all.
Thank you for your letter dated 23rd November.
At Aggregates Industries we take our responsibility to the environment and communities in which we operate very seriously, which is why it is one of our company's strategic pillars.
In response to your letter, I would like to make you aware that shortly, we will be formally submitting additional information for our 2017 planning application to Devon County Council, which will include transport sustainability data.
This will then be published on the County Council's website and subject to formal planning consultation.
Our latest #Sustainability Report is here! It includes details of our initiatives to address a number of challenges, including carbon reduction, circular economy, energy efficiency and site restoration all in the face of a changing climate. Learn more https://t.co/BtleHXERkf pic.twitter.com/Tk2itQrlWp
— Aggregate Industries (@AggregateUK) September 5, 2019
.@AggregateUK Is this 2.5 million mile HGV haulage scheme in #Devon what you mean by #sustainable?? https://t.co/ERcD3UUnDZ #CO2 #climate pic.twitter.com/2P6rEVCLRE
— Straitgate Action Gp (@straitgateactgp) November 16, 2016